Foot in Touch

Entries categorized as ‘Tri Nations’

Australia and New Zealand serve up World Cup warning

September 1, 2011 · Leave a Comment

McCaw and Cooper's ongoing battle typified the physicality and intensity of the TriNations final

Chris Gollop

Australia may have inflicted a second successive defeat on the All Blacks in Brisbane last weekend, but this hugely entertaining match provided no reason to doubt that New Zealand are still firm favourites for the World Cup.

For the duration of the first half, Australia’s performance resembled those we have come to expect from their opposition. Their physicality at the breakdown was astonishing – as was the intensity of their play – and New Zealand seemed to be dead and buried after Samo’s brilliant try. After receiving the ball on his own 10-metre line and casting off Adam Thompson’s weak challenge (who was, it must be said, hampered by an injury), Samo galloped to the try line with ease – a sensational turn of speed for the oldest man ever to have represented Australia in this competition. Dan Vickerman epitomised the Australian effort: he piled into every ruck with total commitment and even acted as scrum-half to feed Samo for his try. Time spent leading Cambridge University certainly has not dulled the ferocity or skill of his play.

New Zealand could not handle Australia’s pace, physicality, or penetration. It was an unexpected performance from both teams: there were plenty of errors from the usually perfect Dan Carter; and New Zealand’s defensive frailties were exposed, particularly around the fringes by the outstanding Will Genia who scored one try and created another for full-back Beale. Australia, on the other hand, showed an edge to their play which has been missing, probably since the last time they won the TriNations in 2001. We all know about Australia’s great backline – any side which can afford to leave Matt Giteau out of their World Cup squad must either be foolish or outrageously talented in that department (or perhaps both); we know that David Pocock is one of the few sevens who can match McCaw’s excellence; but Australia showed, in the TriNations finale, something of which we were previously unsure – that they are up for any fight.

This newfound hardness was highlighted by the supreme defensive effort of the Wallabies in the second half. New Zealand’s resurgence – thanks to some stern words from Graham Henry, no doubt – was largely based on a pick-and-drive game. It was brilliantly executed for Conrad Smith’s try: due reward for twenty-six phases strung together by the New Zealand pack (missing both Thompson and Read through first-half injuries). Nonu ran in another try, but throughout this period of play the Wallabies’ defensive effort was even more impressive than New Zealand’s ball retention and relentless attack.

With the score tied at 20-20 a New Zealand victory seemed inevitable, such was the certainty of their revival. But Genia, searing past Mealamu, found another hole in the black wall and fed Ioane who, as ever, was tracking his run on the inside. Ioane stepped off his right to beat Jane and passed to Beale for a well-worked try.

Australia produced an extraordinary performance. They showed that they are serious contenders for the World Cup (if Cooper can kick his goals) with a hardened edge to their contact work, and a greater hunger for victory. But, worryingly for the rest of the world, a great display from the Wallabies showed just how good this New Zealand team really is: that they can come back so strongly from such a demolition in the first half, and are prepared to grind out results predominantly with their pack demonstrates how seriously New Zealand are taking this World Cup. Australia will probably not play as well as this in the World Cup. But Richie McCaw will certainly not allow his team to get themselves into a 20-3 deficit again.

New Zealand had an off day but still managed to compete with this Australian side on top form. No other team in the world would have got close.

Categories: All Blacks · Australia · RWC 2011 · Tri Nations
Tagged: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Carter preeminent

July 31, 2011 · Leave a Comment

Carter evades young Springbok fly-half Patrick Lambie

Now I’ll be the first to admit that starting a blog by eulogising Dan Carter is hardly the most original step in the world.  However, anyone who watched yesterday’s Tri Nations match between New Zealand and South Africa might understand why I’m writing this.

Dan Carter yesterday became the highest points scorer in Test history, overtaking Jonny Wilkinson with his first penalty kick after three minutes.  Despite this impressive statistic, however, the numbers might suggest that he didn’t have his best game – no tries, only two conversions from six attempts, and a missed penalty.  In addition, he was ‘demoted’ to inside centre for the last fifteen minutes as Colin Slade got some game time at 10, and his second-half included a badly shanked touch-finder that went out on the full and a spillage under no pressure at all near the end.

Never have statistics been more misleading.  Yes, admittedly, he missed a raft of kicks, as he is occasionally prone to do.  But his decision-making, running and creativity were absolutely exceptional.  So exceptional, in fact, that I am for the first time completely convinced that he is the best fly-half in world rugby.  Quade Cooper possesses maverick brilliance; Wilkinson has superb distribution and thunderous defence; but Carter is the only fly-half in the world who can be utterly brilliant without actually looking like he’s trying.

If the All Blacks’ second try was a classic, it was also classic Carter.  Receiving the ball in his 22, he shaped to kick for touch before stabbing a grubber with the outside of his left boot.  Needless to say, the ball was perfectly-weighted for the rampaging Ma’a Nonu, who was dragged down near the halfway line.  The ball was then fizzed to Carter, who immediately dummied and sliced through the disorganised line in front of him, running 20m before a blind offload gave Zac Guildford a jog to the line.

This is a big part of Carter’s value – the ability to create 5 points almost on his own.  He did the it in the Super 15 final, a game in which he was shut-down very effectively by the Reds but still managed to give them a 10-6 lead with a brilliant grubber to himself.  The same was true yesterday – at 8-0 down, the Boks were looking for a big response.  Within a minute, Carter had taken the All Blacks from their own 22 to the opposition try-line, and SA looked totally sunk.

Arguably, of course, Carter shares this ‘moment of magic’ quality with Cooper, who also dismantled the Springboks last week.  Carter, however, combines this clinical, incisive play with superb decision-making.  When he had to kick to touch, he did; when New Zealand were trying to take the sting out of the South African recovery, he played the territory and martialled the defence.  No cross kicks in his own in-goal area for this fly-half.

Even in micro-situations, his instinctive decisions are good.  During one of the All Black counter-attacks yesterday, turnover ball was quickly moved to Carter in the Boks’ half.  It was clear that someone would need to take contact and Carter, after slipping a tackle, straightened the line.  Suddenly, however, he seemed to reconsider, and just before the tackle he fed Ben Franks coming back on the angle.  This not only added a bit of momentum and muscle to the subsequent hit; it crucially meant that Carter was already in the first receiver position by the time Franks hit the ground.  This ability to avoid ruck-situations is a big factor in the All Blacks’ use of quick ball, as Carter is always in position.  It’s also a big part of his try-scoring record, as he is always available for an offload as a support-runner or to take quick ball near the try line, while the defence is still in disarray.

I don’t think Carter is unstoppable, and I’ll blog again on shutting him down nearer the World Cup.  I also think Wilkinson will re-take the points scoring record within the next year.  If I had to pick a fly-half tomorrow, however, I’d go for Carter every time.  Solid defence, brilliant running, great distribution and an eye for a gap are his natural tools; and the rugby brain that deploys them is as good as it gets.

Categories: All Blacks · Players · Tri Nations
Tagged: , , , , , , ,